Competing with ChatGPT-Type Technologies: Patent Counsel and Inventors Need to Up Their Game, Using Creativity and Systematic Thinking Tools

By: John Cronin


In the rapidly changing world of technological advancements, ChatGPT-type technologies emerge as a remarkable innovation. Powered by artificial intelligence, these language models have demonstrated their prowess in automating tasks and producing human-like text. However, concerns have arisen among patent counsels and inventors alike with their widespread adoption. Patent counsels entrusted with sound thinking practices safeguarding intellectual property now adapt to an era where automation has replaced many traditional duties. Simultaneously, inventors who rely on creativity to conceive groundbreaking ideas navigate a landscape where even idea generation is becoming automated. To navigate this transformative terrain, both patent counsels and inventors must embrace creativity and systematic thinking tools, elevating their skills to remain indispensable in the face of ChatGPT technologies. This is no different that Bank Tellers upper their game. Bank tellers were often retrained to take on more complex tasks, such as assisting customers with more advanced financial services, promoting banking products, or focusing on customer relationship management.

The broader impact of automation on employment in various sectors is a subject of ongoing debate and research. While automation may displace certain jobs, it can also create new roles, increase productivity, and lead to overall economic growth. The extent to which automation affects employment depends on the specific context, the pace of technological advancement, and how society and businesses adapt to these changes.

Impact on Patent Counsels

ChatGPT-type technologies have slowly started to impacted patent counsels by automating and replacing many of the services they previously offered. Tasks like prior art searches, patent drafting, and even legal analysis of patents can now be performed with remarkable speed and accuracy using AI-powered tools. While this early automation starts to streamline processes and enhances efficiency, it also means that patent counsels must redefine their roles to remain valuable to their clients, so as Chat-GPT like technologies do no make patent counsels less relevant. Patent counsel may start to focus on higher-level tasks that require human judgment, such as , patent prosecution, more creative thinking for invention development and more systematic thinking to patent more strategically. By harnessing both creative thinking tools and systematic thinking tools, patent counsels can identify new areas for IP protection, identify new ways to overcome legal challenges, and offer tailor-made solutions that set them apart from Chat-GPT like automated services.

Impact on Inventors

ChatGPT-type technologies have opened new avenues of automated idea development and enablement for inventors. These AI systems can assist inventors in brainstorming, providing valuable insights and information to support their creative processes. However, this also means inventors must up their game and leverage these tools effectively to stay competitive. Rather than seeing AI as a threat, inventors can embrace it as a powerful ally in their inventive journey. By combining their inventive thinking with AI-generated insights, inventors can refine their ideas, identify unique selling points, and create more robust patent applications. Additionally, inventors can use systematic thinking approaches to analyze market trends, anticipate consumer needs, and align their inventions with commercial opportunities, ultimately increasing the chances of success in an increasingly competitive landscape.

In this paper we will provide many areas that both patent counsel and inventors can up their game, using creative thinking and systematic thinking tools. Each of these areas has much more detail in the specific tools and examples to use (if you follow the links). These areas are (1) harnessing these tools in training and in real life applications, (2) supercharging patent prosecution with inventors, (3) overcoming prior art, (4) filing the IP white space, (5) forward patenting, (6) patent continuations, and Master Disclosure techniques.

Definition of Creativity Tools

“Creativity tools” refers to strategies and procedures that encourage innovative thinking. These tools act as catalysts, allowing patent counsels and inventors to develop unique ideas and inventions. They make it possible to explore uncharted territories in a structured manner, which increases the likelihood of producing valuable intellectual property.

One example of a creativity tool is associative thinking, where patent counsels and inventors gather to generate a wide range of ideas. Encouraging open and accessible associations allows participants to explore different angles and perspectives, leading to innovative solutions and inventions. During these sessions, they can use techniques like “lions-den” or “visually identifying relationships” to structure their thoughts and uncover new possibilities.

Definition of Systematic Thinking Tools

Systematic thinking tools provide a structured approach to problem-solving by organizing information, exploring alternatives, and facilitating informed decision-making. These tools guide inventors in analyzing complex problems and identifying potential solutions. One example of a systematic thinking tool is the morphological matrix, which breaks down a problem into its constituent elements and explores various combinations to generate novel ideas.

Harnessing Creative Thinking and Systematic Think Tools

[1]Despite working closely with inventive individuals, patent counsel often lacks formal training in creative thinking. However, by embracing tools for creative thinking, they can better understand the “voice of the inventor” and strengthen patent claims by uncovering arguments for non-obviousness. Understanding the inventive thought process enables patent counsel to gain valuable insights, identify creativity tools used by inventors, and facilitate productive brainstorming sessions, resulting in more robust patent applications. Equipped with creative thinking tools, patent counsel can propose inventive workarounds, craft compelling responses to patent examiners, and demonstrate the innovation of inventions beyond existing knowledge. Incorporating creative thinking empowers inventors and the patent process, fostering a culture of innovation within companies and positioning patent counsel as valuable partners and advisors for inventors and businesses. By bridging the gap between legal expertise and inventors’ creative minds, creative thinking revolutionizes the patenting process, navigating complexities, advocating for innovative ideas, and ensuring the adequate protection of intellectual property.

  • Patent counsel often works closely with inventive individuals but receives minimal training in creative thinking themselves.
  • Embracing tools for creative thinking can help patent counsel understand the “voice of the inventor” and strengthen patent claims by unlocking arguments for non-obviousness.
  • Understanding the inventive thought process of inventors allows patent counsel to gain valuable insights that enhance the understanding of novelty and strengthen patent claims.
  • Patent counsel can identify specific creativity tools inventors use during the creative process, helping establish non-obviousness.
  • With a solid grasp of creative thinking, patent counsel can facilitate productive brainstorming sessions with inventors, leading to more robust patent applications.
  • Patent counsel equipped with creative thinking tools can propose inventive workarounds to strengthen patent claims and improve the chances of successful patent protection.
  • Understanding creative thinking enables patent counsel to craft compelling responses to patent examiners, addressing concerns and establishing non-obviousness.
  • By justifying patenting with unique creative thinking tools, patent counsel can demonstrate the invention’s innovation beyond what is known in the art.
  • Incorporating creative thinking into a patent counsel’s skill set empowers inventors and strengthens the patent process, fostering a culture of innovation within companies.
  • Patent counsel can become valuable partners and advisors for inventors and businesses by embracing creative thinking and forward-thinking approaches to patent protection.
  • Embracing creative thinking allows patent counsel to bridge the gap between legal expertise and inventors’ creative minds, revolutionizing the patenting process.
  • Patent counsel with creative thinking tools can navigate patent law complexities, advocate for innovative ideas, and pave the way for groundbreaking inventions.
  • Integrating creative thinking tools in patent counsel’s practice enhances patent quality and ensures adequate intellectual property protection.



Ways to Supercharge Patent Counsel’s Patenting Results

[2]The concept of “Quality through Quantity” emphasizes how patent counsels can leverage the power of “Structured Creativity Tools Based Brainstorming” to improve the quality of inventions they file. By exploring many ideas, patent counsels stimulate creativity and uncover groundbreaking concepts that may have been missed during more limited inventor interviews. Expanding patent specifications with new ideas bolsters the coverage and protection of inventive concepts while drafting multiple dependent claims strengthens the patent portfolio by offering alternative embodiments. Additionally, this approach enables multi-dimensional enablement, ensuring that patent specifications adequately support the core concepts. Moreover, the method facilitates broader prior art searches, helping patent counsels identify existing technologies that may impact novelty and non-obviousness. It also aids in determining inventorship, resolving potential disputes, and ensuring proper recognition. Patent counsels can preserve valuable trade secrets by strategically excluding certain aspects, maintaining a competitive advantage. Embracing “Structured Creativity Tools Based Brainstorming” allows patent counsels to prioritize their patenting efforts strategically, group ideas, and differentiate between patentable and publishable concepts. Moreover, it creates a long-term docket enhancement, serving as a valuable resource for future invention evaluation and facilitating ongoing organizational innovation.

  • Quality through Quantity refers to the idea that generating a large number of ideas can lead to higher-quality inventions and stronger patent protection.
  • Structured Creativity Tools Based Brainstorming: The methodology that encourages generating a large number of ideas through structured brainstorming techniques.
  • Patent counsel in various industries, such as automotive, medical devices, software technology, renewable energy, artificial intelligence, etc., can benefit from this approach.
  • Stimulates creativity: The sheer number of ideas stimulates creativity and leads to groundbreaking concepts that may not emerge in a constrained brainstorming session.
  • Expanding specifications: Continually adding new ideas to the patent specification enhances its coverage and strengthens patent protection.
  • Diverse options for dependent claims: Drafting multiple dependent claims provides alternative embodiments and strengthens the patent portfolio.
  • Multi-dimensional enablement: Exploring ideas from different perspectives improves the enablement aspect of the invention.
  • Broader prior art search: Access to a larger pool of ideas allows for more comprehensive prior art searches, ensuring the novelty and non-obviousness of the invention.
  • Determining inventorship: Helps in tracking and documenting contributions from multiple inventors, resolving disputes and ensuring proper recognition.
  • Unveiling trade secret aspects: Identifying ideas that may be trade secrets helps protect confidential information while pursuing patent protection for other aspects.
  • Strategic planning: Organizing and prioritizing ideas for a more effective patenting strategy.
  • Identifying publishable ideas: Distinguishing between ideas suitable for patents and those for academic or scientific publications optimizes intellectual property strategy.
  • Long-term docket enhancement: Incorporating idea lists into the docket system ensures a continuous flow of new ideas for future inventions.



Using Creativity and Systematic Inventing Tools to Overcome Prior Art

[3]Prior art poses a challenge to inventors seeking patent protection for their inventions. Creativity and systematic inventing tools can help overcome barriers presented by prior art.

Prior art is existing knowledge or public disclosure predating the patented invention. Overcoming prior art involves differentiating the new invention from existing knowledge.

  • It uses the Systematic Tool “Inventing Around Checklist for the Prior Art.” The tool helps identify alternative solutions that circumvent existing prior art.
  • Utilizing the Systematic Thinking Tool “Cross Map”: The technique explores various problem dimensions by identifying connections. It helps uncover novel approaches that overcome the limitations of prior art.
  • Using the Systematic Tool “Morphological Matrix” to Assess Prior Art Coverage: The tool helps comprehensively understand prior art and its coverage. Inventors can identify gaps and unexplored areas for inventive solutions.
  • Utilizing the Creativity Tool “Opposites”: The technique prompts considering opposite characteristics or attributes. It helps uncover unique approaches to overcome the limitations of prior art.
  • Using the Creativity Tool “Random Seed”: The technique involves introducing a random stimulus into the creative process. It sparks new connections and associations, leading to fresh ideas.
  • Using the Creativity Tool “Lion’s Den”: The technique challenges inventors to confront the most daunting aspects of prior art. It helps unleash creativity and devise innovative solutions.



Creativity Tools for Filling the IP White Space: A Guide for Counsel and Inventors Patent Counsels

  • [4]Associative thinking is one such tool, which involves brainstorming and exploring different angles and perspectives to generate innovative solutions.
  • Filing patents in the patent white space refers to targeting areas with few existing patents or lacking inventions, which increases the likelihood of obtaining valuable patents.
  • Analyzing competitors’ patents helps identify gaps in the IP landscape, presenting opportunities to develop superior patents or fill gaps left by competitors.
  • Trend analysis can reveal emerging white spaces where opportunities for innovation exist due to inconsistent trends in patent filings.
  • The “University view” tool allows inventors to identify active universities and research institutions, which can be used to invent practical solutions based on their research.
  • Claim-type analysis helps inventors create new inventions and claims that stand out from the existing landscape.
  • Identifying critical parameter gaps in existing patents allows inventors to stake claims in novel ways and strengthen their IP position.
  • Analyzing the white space in individual inventors’ patents can lead to creating additional features and filing patent claims on top of their inventions.
  • Tools for generating landscape cross maps compare frequently and infrequently used claim elements, uncovering sources for new claims and patent opportunities.



Patent Counsels and Inventors Could Use Creativity Tools to Direct Invention for Forward-Patents

[5]Patent counsels and inventors are essential members of the team that assists companies and individuals in navigating the process of obtaining patents. Throughout history, their primary concern has been ascertaining whether proposed inventions satisfy the prerequisites for receiving a patent. However, patent counsels and inventors can go beyond obtaining a patent by incorporating creativity tools to obtain more “Forward patents” as well.

  • Forward patenting involves anticipating and securing patent protection for future technological developments in the industry.
  • Patent counsels and inventors strategically direct the invention process toward creating forward patents with long-term value.
  • Supply chain thinking involves considering suppliers’ participation in the invention process to leverage their expertise.
  • Customer chain thinking entails looking at the patent’s impact from the customer’s perspective to identify new areas for invention.
  • Business model thinking helps envision future economic landscapes and monetization opportunities for patents.
  • Time-scale thinking considers how patents will be used across different time horizons.
  • Changing the claim type thinking involves exploring various claims to broaden the patent’s protection and scope.
  • How-why thinking abstracts the patent to identify potential improvements and alternative embodiments?
  • Invent underneath thinking analyzes the fundamental aspects of the patent to generate ideas for enhancements.
  • Patent counsels can use these creativity tools to maximize the value and impact of patents on various products and technologies.



Unlocking Inventive Possibilities: How Patent Counsels Leverage Creativity Tools and Master Disclosure for Patent Continuations

[6] Patent counsels play an essential part in the ever-evolving world of intellectual property by ensuring the inventive process is protected and directing it in the right direction. Their expertise extends beyond legal matters in shaping and refining patent specifications in collaboration with inventors. This article investigates the potential advantages of using “creativity tools” and “master disclosures” to direct invention for patent continuations, aiming to improve the quality and scope of patents.

  • Understanding Patent Continuations: Patent continuations allow inventors to build upon a previously filed patent application, expanding its claims and scope. Continuation applications fall under patent law and require the addition of original subject matter to be eligible. Considering market requirements and recent technological developments, inventive subject matter enhances the patent’s value and competitiveness.
  • Unleashing Creativity Tools: Patent counsels use creativity tools like associative thinking, taking the opposite approach, and visually identifying relationships. Associative thinking connects unrelated concepts to uncover innovative solutions. Taking the opposite approach challenges inventors to consider alternatives and leads to novel insights. Visualizing relationships using tools like mind mapping helps identify gaps and potential improvements.
  • The Power of Master Disclosure: A well-structured master disclosure is crucial in patenting. It ensures all essential details are captured, minimizing the risk of omissions. A comprehensive master disclosure enhances the patent’s value and defensibility.
  • Expanding Specifications to All System Elements: Patent counsels help inventors expand patent specifications to cover all aspects of the system. This maximizes the potential of the patent and leads to a more comprehensive continuation.
  • Embracing the Future of Technology: Patent counsels can anticipate technological advancements and incorporate them into patent continuations. This proactive approach keeps inventors ahead of the competition and protects future developments.
  • Viewing Specifications from the Customer’s Perspective: Patent counsels consider the customer’s perspective to develop patent specifications catering to market requirements.
  • Considering the Supplier’s Perspective: Patent counsels also analyze the supplier ecosystem to identify collaboration and licensing opportunities, enhancing the patent’s commercial viability.
  • Navigating the IPLandscape: Patent counsels create an ipLandscape of related areas to understand the impact and relevance of the invention in the market.
  • Exploring Invent Arounds: Patent counsels assist inventors in identifying alternative solutions that do not infringe on existing patents, providing a competitive advantage.



ChatGPT-type technologies have undoubtedly revolutionized the landscape of intellectual property and invention. For patent counsels, embracing creativity and systematic thinking tools is vital to remain valuable in this new era where many tasks are automated. By focusing on higher-level tasks that demand human judgment and expertise, patent counsels can set themselves apart from AI-powered tools and offer tailor-made solutions to their clients. On the other hand, inventors can harness the power of AI as an ally in their inventive journey, combining innovative thinking with AI-generated insights to refine ideas and create more robust patent applications. By embracing creativity and systematic thinking, inventors can analyze market trends, anticipate consumer needs, and align their inventions with commercial opportunities, ensuring success in a competitive landscape.

As technology advances, integrating creativity and systematic thinking tools will play an increasingly crucial role in navigating the complexities of intellectual property and fostering a culture of innovation. For patent counsels and inventors alike, mastering these tools will improve the quality and scope of patents and unlock new inventive possibilities and secure their positions in an ever-changing world of invention and intellectual property. By strategically leveraging creativity and systematic thinking tools, patent counsels and inventors can supercharge their patenting results, overcome prior art challenges, fill the IP white space, and direct inventions toward securing valuable forward patents that shape the future of technology. As we move into an era dominated by AI and technological advancements, the collaboration between human ingenuity and AI-powered tools will be the key to staying ahead and thriving in the world of intellectual property.